| 8/24 | A | St Thomas Aquinas (2-8) | [7:25] | L | 6-41 | |
| 9/1 | A | Valley Christian School (5-6) | [7:25] | L | 12-33 | |
| 9/8 | H | Columbus Crusaders (club) (2-7) | W* | 8-0 | ||
| 9/14 | A | Crestwood (5-5) | [5:17] | L | 7-48 | |
| 9/22 | A | Trinity (2-8) | [6:21] | W | 42-28 | |
| 9/29 | A | University School (4-6) | [3:10] | L | 18-46 | |
| 10/6 | A | Linsly (WV) (5-4) | [6:0] | C* | cancelled | |
| 10/12 | H | North (0-10) | [3:9] | W | 31-12 | |
| 10/20 | H | Kiski Prep (PA) (4-3) | L | 13-28 | ||
| 10/27 | H | Hawken (0-9) | [5:17] | W | 41-14 | |
| * - game does not count in OHSAA rankings | ||||||