| 9/11 | H | Wyoming Seminary (PA) (1-1) | L | 6-23 | ||
| 9/18 | H | Ridley College (ON) (0-1) | W | 62-13 | ||
| 9/25 | H | The Academy (PA) (0-6) | W | 60-6 | ||
| 10/2 | A | Valley Forge Military Academy (PA) (1-0) | L | 14-32 | ||
| 10/9 | H | Linsly (WV) (4-2) | L | 13-31 | ||
| 10/15 | A | Lorain Catholic (4-6) | [6:21] | W | 60-18 | |
| 10/23 | H | The Hill School (PA) (0-1) | W | 22-0 | ||
| 10/30 | A | University School (4-6) | [3:9] | L | 0-28 | |
| 11/6 | A | Kiski Prep (PA) (5-3) | L* | 0-38 | ||
| * - game does not count in OHSAA rankings | ||||||