| 8/20 | A | Mechanicsburg (12-1) | [VI:24] | L | 28-35 | |
| 8/27 | H | Bethel (1-9) | [V:20] | W | 47-25 | |
| 9/3 | H | Benjamin Logan (4-6) | [V:18] | W | 52-28 | |
| 9/10 | A | North Union (8-3) | [V:18] | L | 0-35 | |
| 9/17 | H | Urbana (2-8) | [IV:16] | W | 55-14 | |
| 9/24 | A | Shawnee (7-5) | [V:20] | L | 7-35 | |
| 10/1 | H | Jonathan Alder (6-5) | [III:11] | L | 21-24 | |
| 10/8 | A | London (10-3) | [III:11] | L | 7-53 | |
| 10/15 | A | Bellefontaine (7-5) | [III:11] | L | 20-21 | ot |
| 10/22 | H | Tecumseh (4-6) | [II:8] | L | 7-9 |