| 8/30 | H | St Charles (4-6) | [2:8] | L | 21-28 | |
| 9/6 | A | New Albany (7-3) | [1:3] | L | 24-28 | |
| 9/13 | A | Whitehall-Yearling (6-4) | [2:8] | W | 49-14 | |
| 9/20 | H | Dublin Jerome (9-3) | [1:2] | L | 17-25 | |
| 9/27 | A | Delaware Hayes (3-7) | [1:2] | W | 29-17 | |
| 10/4 | A | Hilliard Bradley (4-6) | [1:2] | W | 38-36 | |
| 10/11 | H | Worthington Kilbourne (1-9) | [2:7] | W | 30-14 | |
| 10/18 | H | Olentangy Berlin (6-5) | [2:7] | L | 29-32 | |
| 10/25 | A | Thomas Worthington (4-6) | [1:3] | L | 27-30 | 2 ot |
| 11/1 | H | Hilliard Darby (7-3) | [1:3] | L | 14-35 |