| 8/27 | A | Penn Hills (PA) (0-3) | W | 50-42 | ||
| 9/2 | A | Highland (OH) (6-4) | [2:6] | L | 28-30 | |
| 9/9 | A | St Vincent-St Mary (OH) (7-5) | [3:9] | W | 27-7 | |
| 9/24 | A | McDonogh School (MD) (1-0) | L | 20-36 | ||
| 10/15 | A | St Edward (OH) (9-3) | [1:1] | L | 7-35 | |
| 10/21 | A | Aurora (OH) (10-2) | [2:5] | L | 13-36 | |
| 10/28 | A | Steubenville (OH) (13-2) | [4:15] | L | 27-39 | |
| 11/5 | A | Suffield Academy (CT) (0-1) | W* | 36-35 | ||
| * - game does not count in OHSAA rankings | ||||||