| 8/20 | H | Newark Catholic (14-2) | [VII:27] | L | 8-34 | |
| 8/27 | A | Woodward (0-10) | [III:10] | W | 43-6 | |
| 9/3 | A | Bishop Watterson (5-6) | [III:11] | L | 7-24 | |
| 9/10 | H | Buckeye Valley (5-5) | [III:11] | W | 23-13 | |
| 9/17 | A | Columbus Academy (8-5) | [V:19] | L | 14-28 | |
| 9/24 | H | Harvest Prep (10-3) | [V:19] | L | 7-25 | |
| 10/1 | A | Whitehall-Yearling (6-4) | [II:7] | L | 25-26 | |
| 10/8 | H | Bexley (3-7) | [IV:15] | W | 26-0 | |
| 10/15 | H | Grandview Heights (2-7) | [VI:23] | W | 36-0 | |
| 10/22 | A | KIPP Columbus (7-5) | [VI:23] | W | 15-14 | |
| 10/30 | A | # Ridgewood (10-2) | [V:19] | L | 6-35 | |
| # - Ohio playoff game | ||||||