| 8/25 | H | Olentangy Orange (9-2) | [1:2] | L | 7-32 | |
| 9/1 | A | Big Walnut (4-6) | [2:7] | W | 21-14 | ot |
| 9/8 | H | Springfield (6-4) | [2:6] | L | 14-24 | |
| 9/15 | A | Thomas Worthington (4-6) | [1:2] | W | 26-25 | ot |
| 9/22 | A | Bishop Hartley (11-2) | [3:11] | L | 17-45 | |
| 9/29 | H | Delaware Hayes (3-7) | [1:2] | W | 31-0 | |
| 10/6 | A | Dublin Scioto (5-5) | [2:7] | L | 21-34 | |
| 10/13 | H | Hilliard Darby (7-4) | [1:3] | L | 3-17 | |
| 10/19 | A | Hilliard Bradley (11-1) | [1:3] | L | 21-63 | |
| 10/27 | H | Dublin Jerome (7-4) | [1:2] | L | 7-24 |