| 9/16 | H | Mercersburg Academy (1-0) | L | 16-51 | ||
| 9/23 | A | Wyoming Seminary (2-0) | L | 6-38 | ||
| 9/30 | A | Western Reserve Academy (OH) (6-2) | [5:0] | L | 19-47 | |
| 10/7 | A | Tuscarawas Central Catholic (OH) (1-9) | [6:23] | W | 23-7 | |
| 10/13 | A | Linsly (WV) (5-5) | [6:0] | W | 27-6 | |
| 10/21 | A | University School (OH) (4-6) | [3:9] | L | 14-17 | |
| 10/28 | H | The Academy (0-5) | [5:0] | W | 44-0 | |
| 11/4 | A | Valley Forge Military Academy (1-0) | L* | 13-31 | ||
| * - game does not count in OHSAA rankings | ||||||